When deciding between FD or MF, the investor is left confused. Whereas FDs have always been the conventional safe investment, Mutual Funds are fast becoming a promising investment option with a chance to earn better returns. In this comprehensive handbook, we shall discuss the major differences between FD vs MF and also why intelligent investors are increasingly choosing Mutual Funds.
Understanding FD vs MF
Before diving into the reasons, let’s clarify the basics of FD vs MF:
Fixed Deposits (FDs)
Nature:
Fixed Deposits compel a person to put money in a bank or financial institution for a specified amount of time. Money is tied up for the said period of time, and it can be for a couple of months or years. Fixed interest rates are provided to the investors, and they remain constant irrespective of the market or economic conditions. It gives a sure and simple investment option.
Returns:
The Fixed Deposit interest is constant and does not vary at all during the period of investment. The fixed rate of interest guarantees that the investors are well acquainted with how much return they will get once the term duration elapses.
Unlike market-linked products, the returns of the FD do not fluctuate with market movement, and there is absolute certainty and return security regardless of what transpires in the economy outside.
Risk:
Fixed Deposits are safe investments since the amount of money is guaranteed, and they are suitable for conservative investors. The money is generally safe, especially when it is deposited with reputable banks or financial institutions. The risk-free aspect is attractive to investors who desire safe and secure returns without exposing themselves to market risks or capital loss.
Liquidity:
FDs of lower liquidity allow for front-end withdrawals but typically impose penalties or reduced interest. Investors should be ready to lock their money with the chosen term of investment for maximum returns. Flexibility is offered, but withdrawals regularly can erode overall returns and reduce the value of the investment as a savings tool.
Taxation:
Interest earned on Fixed Deposits falls under the likelihood of being taxed in full as per the income tax bracket of the investor. In other words, those with higher income may be required to shell out a large portion of their FD interest as tax. Banks also deduct Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) if interest earned exceeds a certain amount, and investors must declare interest from FD while declaring taxes.
Mutual Funds (MFs)
Nature:
Mutual Funds pool funds from numerous investors to create a huge corpus managed by able fund managers. They invest in diversified portfolios of equities, debt, or a mix of both for the best risk-reward management. Mutual Funds give small investors access to a variety of securities with the benefit of professional management and diversification not feasible to an individual.
Returns:
Mutual Fund returns are market-linked, i.e., they depend on the performance of the underlying securities. While they yield greater returns than deposits, the returns are not guaranteed and are dependent on investment risks. The returns actually depend on market performance, fund strategy, and the asset classes chosen, i.e., MF returns are not guaranteed but can be more yielding in the long term.
Risk:
The risk exposure in Mutual Funds is extremely wide-ranging, from low-risk debt funds to high-risk equity funds. There is the option for investors to choose funds based on risk tolerance and investment horizon. Debt funds carry fixed returns with minimal risk, while equity funds are market-sensitive with high growth potential. This provides insurance investors with an option to align risk with the investment horizon.
Liquidity:
Open-ended Mutual Funds are liquid. They can be redeemed at short notice on the prevailing Net Asset Value (NAV) without large penalties, and thus their money remains accessible. This facility benefits investors who may need money at short notice, as against fixed deposits with fixed lock-ins and prepayment penalties.
Taxation:
Taxation of Mutual Funds depends on the type of fund and duration of holding. Equity funds are charged on long-term capital gains with some exemptions up to a level, and debt funds enjoy indexation relief on long-term holding, keeping tax to a minimum. Taxation of short-term gains is either by way of income slabs or slab rates, and hence, tax planning is required to achieve maximum after-tax returns.
Why Smart Investors are Shifting to MFs from FDs: 5 Reasons
1. Potential for Higher Returns
In the FD vs MF debate, MFs win on growth potential:
Market-Linked Growth:
Mutual funds, or equity funds, provide longer-term gains as they are invested in the share market. This provides them with the prospect of gaining from market growth, company performance, and general economic growth. These returns compound one on the other in the long run, which makes MFs worthwhile for investors who think in a long-term capital appreciation framework compared to FDs.
Diversification:
Mutual Funds diversify between equities, debt, and other investment options, thus spreading the risk. The mix of such an asset reduces the impact of underperformance in one area while collecting rewards from others. The diversification makes MFs a better-balanced and potentially lucrative choice over single-asset vehicles like FD.
Professional Management:
Mutual Funds are handled by expert fund managers on the basis of research, analysis, and market intelligence taking investment decisions. Their active portfolio management with an eye to earning maximum returns while managing risks aids in the generation of value for the investor and thus stands as a better choice than traditional ones such as Fixed Deposits that cannot be altered easily.
Example: In the span of 5 years, whereas FDs can yield about 6-7%, equity mutual funds have the ability to provide 10-12% or higher based on the state of the market.
2. Tax Efficiency
FD vs MF taxation starkly favors MFs:
FDs: Interest on Fixed Deposits is taxable and forms part of the investor’s overall income, taxed as per their income tax slab. It can equate to forking out as much as 30% of it for high-income taxpayers, reducing real returns significantly. This is in contrast to Mutual Funds, which are known to offer tax-efficient investment options.
MFs, Equity Funds: Excess returns of ₹1 lakh and above (holding period > 1 year) are exempt; excess returns above the same are subject to a tax of 10% without indexation.
Debt Funds: Long-term capital gains (holding period > 3 years) are subject to a tax of 20% with the advantage of indexation, reducing the incidence of tax.
This tax efficacy makes MFs all the more attractive, especially for long-term investors.
3. Liquidity and Flexibility
FD or MF for emergencies? MFs win:
Redemption:
Open-ended Mutual Funds have liquidity of high order, whereby units are redeemable at will without incurring rigorous penalties. Exit liquidity gives easy access to money in times of emergencies or upon a change in financial needs. In comparison with FDs having lock-ins and penalties on premature withdrawal, MFs offer easier exit avenues to investors.
SIP and SWP Options:
SIPs and SWPs render Mutual Funds highly flexible. SIPs enable regular disciplined investment intending to create wealth in the long run, while SWPs deliver regular income by periodically withdrawing pre-specified amounts. This two-pronged advantage helps in accumulation and distribution goals, making MFs even more flexible compared to traditional products like FDs without having similar structured options.
Diversification of Schemes:
Mutual Funds come in a variety of schemes—equity, debt, hybrid, etc.—so that there is something available for each investor’s preference, with personal risk-bearing capacity and desired goals. Aggressive or conservative, short-term or long-term, there’s a fund to match every profile, and hence, MFs are more appropriate than fixed-return products like Fixed Deposits.
FDs, however, are ridden with tenures, and withdrawal before term attracts charges and lower rates of interest.
4. Inflation-Beating Potential
Are mutual funds safer than FDs against inflation? Yes:
FDs:
If the interest rate on Fixed Deposits cannot be higher than inflation, the real rate of return on the investment goes into negative. It means the purchasing power of money decreases over time. Conversely, Mutual Funds, particularly equities, have the potential to generate returns that beat inflation, which allow the investors to increase and save money in the long run.
MFs:
Equity and part-debt Mutual Funds have the ability to generate more than inflation, thereby enabling the investors to keep and increase the real value of the funds. By making investments in assets that are wealth-generating or inflation-indexed securities, these funds give more scope to build wealth over a span of time in comparison to fixed returns on products like Fixed Deposits.
Thus, for long-term generation of wealth, MFs can prove to be a safer alternative than inflation.
5. Diversification and Professional Management
FD Vs MF on expertise:
Diversification:
Diversification, in the context of Mutual Funds, means investment in a variety of asset classes like stocks, bonds, and money market instruments. This prevents colossal losses on a single investment. By diversifying various assets, investors have more stable returns and are protected from shifts in the market, hence enhancing overall portfolio stability.
Expertise:
Professional fund managers offer expertise by carrying out trend research in the market, analyzing securities, and continuously managing portfolios. Expertise allows the optimization of returns via informed decisions regarding the asset allocation, buying undervalued stocks, and minimizing risks. Expert handling offers value that would be out of an individual investor’s capability to offer individually.
Accessibility:
Investment becomes easy and convenient through Mutual Funds, even for small investors, as they can co-own professionally managed diversified funds. This dispenses with the need for huge capital or knowledge. Small investments can be made and still benefit from professional management and risk dispersal, thus, investment is easy and accessible.
FDs, being individual investments, lack this dispersal of risk and professionalism of management.
FD vs MF: Comparative Snapshot
Are mutual funds safer than FD?
While FD or MF safety depends on perspective:
Risk Profile:
Fixed Deposits (FDs) are safe with fixed returns and capital protection.
Mutual Funds (MFs) have market risks; returns fluctuate with market performance.
Return Potential:
FDs offer fixed but comparatively lower returns than MFs.
MFs, particularly equity funds, may offer greater returns in the longer term but with a higher fluctuating rate.
Capital Safety:
FDs keep your principal amount secure.
MFs do not provide protection of principal; it can increase or decrease.
Liquidity:
MFs will provide improved liquidity with simple redemption terms.
FDs provide the facility of prepayment of withdrawal charges.
Summary:
FDs are safer as far as preservation of capital is concerned.
MFs are for those who are ready to take prudent risks for the hope of higher MF Returns.
FD or MF is your choice based on the risk acceptance and money requirement.
MF Returns vs FD Returns
-
- Fixed Deposits (FD) Returns
- Give a fixed, assured rate of interest.
- Average 5% to 7% pa (bank floating rate based on tenure).
- Fixed returns irrespective of the market.
- MF Returns (Mutual Fund):
- Performance-based and market-linked, based on assets.
- Equity mutual funds have returned 10% to 15 %+ in the long term.
- Debt funds give average returns, better than F D but risky.
Interest vs Risk:
FD gives low but certain returns.
MFs give higher potential returns but have market risk and volatility.
Impact of Inflation:
FD return cannot be more than inflation, lowering the real return.
MFs, especially equity MF Returns, will be more than inflation, supporting growth in wealth.
Summary:
FDs are suitable for conservative investors requiring protection.
MFs are suitable for investors who want high growth and have a long time horizon.
Conclusion
The FD vs MF choice depends on risk appetite and goals. Although FDs are safe and have assured returns, they are not suitable for creating wealth in the long term, considering inflation and the cost of rising taxes. MF Returns, offering room for improved returns, tax effectiveness, and flexibility, offers a favorable investment platform for monetary growth.
We realize the intricacy of VSRK Capital investment options. We are in a position to assist you in selecting suitable Mutual Funds schemes according to your investment objective and risk tolerance. Still confused – MF vs FD? Consult our experts for personalized advice!, feel free to contact us.
Get more information by visiting us on Google.
